Diagnosing vs. Understanding: The Epistemology of Psychiatric Diagnostics as a Societal Phenomenon
There’s a difference between diagnosing people and understanding them. Many don’t know the difference. Often it seems the more one learns of the former, the less perspective they have on the latter. KNOWING means knowing the facts; UNDERSTANDING means knowing how they fit together. Diagnosing is implicitly synonymous with understanding but actually means knowing how the facts fit a preconceived model in a highly inexact science. PSYCHOLOGICALLY, understanding is all that’s required. At best, diagnosing is a means to that end. Even PSYCHIATRICALLY, precise dialogistic specificity is rarely if ever necessary. Basic reasoning alone tells you diagnostics are catalysts for confusion and bias, increasing vulnerability to inconsistent beliefs and twisting the facts AWAY from each other. That said, extralogical reasoning (ER), or at least its creator, does not wholesale “reject” psychiatric diagnoses, nor deny that there may be...